Post by Lindelwen on May 8, 2005 9:38:08 GMT -5
Twippo
Comments on Twippo's Banner:
Well, here's my fav. really good colours, awesome blended, I just don't have what to say. I gave you a ten! Nice background, but could have used a little more effect. Though I've seen this effect often, you've done an excellent job of using these pictures to your best. Though the blend job could have been a little better
Calanfalathiel
Comments on Calanfalathiel's Banner:
Very beautiful blend, very nice colours but I think these effects are too much, I mean I don't like banners full of stars... (just isn't my style). I gave you an eight. Kinda small, but graphics are good. You have made a gourgeous banner. I've seen this pic combination often but you took them and inovated them into your own style. The purple shading and stars are gorgeous. Thought the pic of Aragorn and their son could have been a bit clearer, it's wonderful.
Melian
Comments on Melian's Banner:
I can't beleive it's yours, I mean you could make it better. The pictures you used are wonderful but I don't like the colours. I gave you a four. Melian-Wow! Well done! You have made a fabulous banner. It's smooth and the quality is great. Though I wouldn't have included the pic of Elrond in the background. The green shading is very Legolasish.
Leggieluver: - Nice banner but you could make it better ! Well, the blend is nice but you could put more colours in it. I gave you a six. Leggyluver- Good skill of graphics. The pics you choose are very nice but could have been clearer, especially over to the right. The blend job is good but needs a little work. I love the choose of text and style; very eyecatching.
Ithil - nice blend but I don't like these butterflys, it just isn't my style. You could put more colour in it. I gave you a five. Good skill of graphics. You have created one of the best Haldir banners I've seen. The picture combination is very nice And the butterflies are a cute personal touch, though they don't quite go with Haldir and the dark shading.
Pippin - first, nice sunrise but I think the banner isn't very good blended. I gave you a four. Love that quote! You have done a very nice job with the bright and firey impression of your banner. It's different then most banners I've seen with this quote and is simple yet well made. Though the text could have been clearer.
Telturwen Tarien - really beautiful banner, very good blended and has nice effects but I don't like pink (well, sorry), so I gave you an eight. Wow, wow, wow! You have done a gourgeous job on this banner. The pink is so unique and beautiful. Usually the Lady is only associated with blue or white. You have taken two ordinary pictures and done wonders with them. Though the pic on the right could have been a tinsy bit clearer. Very nice job!
Maranwe - you know I love your banners, very well blended... I don't have what to say really, I gave you a nine. Love the effects and font. This is a very nice Lothlorien banner. Though it needs more color and the pictures could have been clearer. The blend job is alright.
Nadana - well, it isn't very well blended, it should have more colours in common. I gave you a three. (the same for Nadana 2) Good blending, luv the font. You have done a beautiful blend job and the choice of pictures is very nice. Though I would suggest adding a bit more to it, because it seems a bit plain. You done a great job in picture and word selection though the blending could have been a bit better on this one.
pirateoftherings - very nice blended (cool font actually) but the colours should fit and they don't very well. I gave you a six. (the same for pirateoftherings 2) Love the effect, well done. The picture and word selection is a wonderful combination. This banner really shows what the elves are and their future. Though the quality could have been better and you could have added some more designing.
The blend job and picture quality could have been better but nice selection of words and pics. The text was a bit blurry as well.
LOTRFreak - good blend but the banner needed more colour. I gave you a five. well done! Hope to see more of those.
The pictures are good though the blend job could have been better and it's a bit plain.
Congratulations to all of the winners, and be sure to thank our judges, Zeth Skywalker a.k.a Elenanna, Arien Elensar, and Lady Undomiel!
.
There I was feeling all forgotten!
